THEINDEX

Technology

AI Is Challenging the Boundaries of Software Ownership

AI is making software easier to reverse engineer, raising new questions about ownership.

By Eddie Mitchell 20 November 2026 5 min read

AI Is Challenging the Boundaries of Software Ownership

Want to use a free open-source version of Adobe’s creative suite? Or how about playing Mario Kart inside Call of Duty? 

Now that AI agents and LLMs can reverse engineer pretty much any slice of software, everything has suddenly become open source, malleable, and combinable. The thousands of tangled and obfuscated lines of code in software and video games that were the primary security layer have been melted away. 

This may be the golden age of retro preservation, mods, and open sourcing, but it could also spell the end of commercial software as we know it.

It’s more likely the beginning of an entirely new era, where the gaps created by hardware abandonment, expensive subscription services, and high access barriers come crashing down.

It’s like how MySpace, SoundCloud, and other modern technologies emerged to solve the need for a record label to publish and distribute an album. Much earlier, literature was produced and disseminated by the church. The printing press similarly upended that era.

The scale with AI is even greater, but the nature of it remains the same. Some people will win, some people will lose.  

I found a 20-year cybersecurity veteran, a video game modder, and a vibe-coding game publisher to help me understand who.

A Restructuring

It can take a human anywhere from a day to years to unscramble variables, trace every function, and decipher structural patterns in a codebase's logic. In some cases, it would be impossible to achieve in a human’s lifetime. 

But now LLMs automate deobfuscation, map out architecture in moments, and translate raw assembly language into text humans can read.

Matthew Stanley, a software engineer and lifelong game modder, explained that initially, he wasn’t using AI to mod games or reverse-engineer them to work in ways they weren’t designed to. But he says it has opened up new realms of possibilities. And so now he can.

“It didn’t fundamentally change why I do this, but it radically changed what I could realistically accomplish,” he tells The Index. “It has, without exaggeration, allowed me to be 100x–1000x more productive. It has permitted me to work outside my areas of expertise.”

Indeed, AI has begun to augment our capabilities as individuals, ultimately peeling power away from enterprises once incentivized to build, innovate, and distribute. So if any piece of software can be cracked wide open, proprietary systems and intellectual property (IP) may be a thing of the past.

“Thistle,” a 20-year tech and cybersecurity veteran, notes this may also spell trouble for the open source community. If people can simply point an LLM at an open source project and produce a desired outcome with “the integration and bells and whistles” they want, why pay for it? Why offer financial support of any kind?  

Thistle explains that if you’re a company that offers an API, then your customers are now writing their own product(s). If you’re offering API docs, customers can rebuild these products from scratch. If you're publishing an open-source version, well, then “your customers can build licensed ports.”

Keeping Up

Is reverse engineering software a hobby that sits between piracy and activism? Or is it a natural end point of human curiosity? Thistle notes that there’s room for individuals to “tear down” big and slow institutions, but disagrees that it’s an act of piracy: “Reverse engineering is something people, governments, and militaries have done for decades, even prior to AI and even prior to software itself. It’s not an uncommon practice.”

Under U.S. law, reverse engineering isn’t considered unlawful in most circumstances. 

Nate Partin, a gamer and vibe coder who heads up content and marketing for browser-based game publishing site Wavedash, explains that this practice of imitation and replication predates AI and software.

“This would usually always happen,” he says. “Is it ethical? No. Is it inevitable, AI or not? Yes. Humans have been copying and stealing things bar for bar since the dawn of time.”

He admits that AI accelerates the process and it makes sense that devs fear AI could steal a developers game or project “bar for bar,” and remade by a teenager with a Claude subscription: “I have bad news: it’s probably going to happen.”

Moving at Great Speeds

At the end of the day, there’s a human cost to all of this. That’s not to say everything is entirely lost.

Matthew acknowledges that the tech is immensely powerful and “basically threatens to undermine many jobs at once,” but at least it won’t replace “all” software engineers, as, well, you still need people on deck to lead the models, not be led by them.

He explains that he’s built new products for the sales team, increasing revenues, and recently wrote a tool in 3 days that replaced a $20,000-per-year vendor.

It’s probably better to get with the times, Nate posits. To him, AI tools are akin to a superpower that “should” be taken advantage of. Whether we like it or not, the tech is snowballing, it’s rolling, “and you better vibe-code a strong sled before it catches up to you and flattens you.”

In the case of Matthew’s development, this is true. He just saved his company $20k a year, which is ultimately a huge loss to the aforementioned vendor. Matthew notes: “Companies that don’t adopt it whatsoever will be eaten by their successful competitors who do.”

Uncertainty is in the air for digital industries. Someone with a $200/month AI subscription could potentially outperform a AAA studio and its dozens of employees. Ultimately, it’s completely upended the financial expectations for game development. 

“Something like GTA 6 could have been built in 1/20th of the time and budget if it started now vs back in 2012.”

Optimistically, 100-person teams could now, theoretically, build games or software packages that are 100x better. Therefore, smaller, leaner teams stand to win big if they embrace AI, as do major studios. 

Prior to AI, quality assurance (QA) testers were an essential component in the software/game development industry. These were/are humans hired to pore over code they didn't write in order to find out what works and what doesn’t.

The upside is that the AI era makes QA a “profoundly more important” role, according to Matthew, who says that “human-in-the-loop involvement” will remain essential.

To protect proprietary systems and IP, Thistle advocates robust cryptographic trust and signing (as seen in blockchain systems, for example), as well as closed source code. But regardless of the technical innovations that could be leveraged, Thistle feels this will all be on the losing side “because it’s such an uphill battle.”

Something Old, Something New

The music and film industries were battling piracy (bootlegging) long before the digital age. In the online era of Limewire and Napster, they feared being destroyed outright. But that didn’t come to pass. The industry simply adapted.

SoundCloud and Spotify have created a saturated market, yet quality musicians and artists still manage to break through. These platforms and the technologies surrounding them have democratized access like never before.

Perhaps this AI era is just the same. Specialized skills are no longer a requirement. Anyone with a mild interest in software/game development and an internet connection can now participate, create, publish, and distribute at great speeds.

It’s funny how the more things change, the more they stay the same. 

Much of the “SoundCloud rapper” AI slop saturation is inevitable. It’s already here. But that doesn’t mean it’s already over for human creativity and digital industries. It’s just another problem for humans to solve and outperform.

Share this story
LinkedIn X Email
Written by

Eddie Mitchell

Since 2017, Eddie has covered fringe tech, geopolitics, and the stranger corners of Web3. He's now a contributor to The Index and recently leaped into the wild world of content creation as a Twitch streamer and YouTube creator.